‘Supergirl’ Singer Breaks Silence on Viral Cover!
Kelty Greye, the voice behind the melancholic Jimmy Eat World cover in ‘Supergirl,’ opens up about the internet’s wild reaction.
7/8/2026, 10:55:12 PM

Pop music sensation Kelty Greye is finally speaking out after her haunting rendition of a 2001 rock anthem went stratospheric thanks to the new "Supergirl" movie. The singer, known for her soulful voice, is making headlines as her cover ignites a firestorm of online debate.
Greye reveals to The Hollywood Reporter that she actually recorded this iconic cover three years before it ever graced the big screen. Talk about perfect timing! It seems fate had a plan for this track all along.
The "Supergirl" team clearly has an ear for talent, plucking this gem from relative obscurity and thrusting it into the spotlight. Now, the internet can't get enough – or some, can't stand – Greye's unique take on the classic.

Fans are divided, with some hailing Greye's version as a stroke of genius, elevating the song to new emotional depths. Others are less impressed, clinging to the original and questioning Greye's artistic choices. The comments sections are a battleground of musical opinions.
Greye herself admits to being overwhelmed by the sheer volume of responses.
Advertisement
DAILY DROP
Get the gossip in your inbox
Hottest celebrity stories, hand-picked daily. No spam, just chaos.
More in music
Little Mix Star’s Family Just Got Bigger, Again!
Bone Thugs-N-Harmony Grab Hollywood Star, Fans Go Wild!
Cool Fan Craze: Concertgoers Swear By This $12 Gadget!

Tori Amos Fans Panic: Last-Minute Tickets Vanish for NYC Show!
Pop Stars Bare Their Souls: The Dark Side of Fame Revealed

Bieber Steals World Cup Halftime Show?!
Advertisement